Practice Matters

Record Keeping: Is it preferable to keep paper or electronic files?

Record-Keeping

This article was updated September 2024 and September 2025.

 

Registrants (or the organization they work for) are free to choose whichever record-keeping system is best suited to their needs and access to technology. The same principles apply to both paper and electronic record-keeping. For example, modifications to any record need to be tracked. In other words, the originals must not be overridden or erased.

 

Security of paper records would include locking and storage, while for electronic records it would include encryption, virus prevention, backups, and physically restricting access to the computer and display. When using electronic record-keeping systems, an alternate process for record-keeping must be ready in case the electronic system is down or unavailable. Review CRPO’s Professional Practice Standard 5.6: Record Storage, Security, & Retrieval for more detail.

 

Question: 

I have been using paper in the past and want to switch to electronic record-keeping. Can I scan and destroy the paper copies?

 

Answer:

There are options when it comes to transitioning from paper to electronic record-keeping. Registrants may either

  • convert all existing paper records into electronic form; or
  • retain paper records and begin entering information into an electronic format on a subsequent basis.

 

In either case, client care and appropriate record-keeping practices must continue without interruption.

 

When scanning paper records, registrants are responsible for ensuring their integrity upon conversion into electronic format. This includes verifying that documents have been properly scanned and that the entire record is intact, including any attached documents and notes. Registrants should establish specific procedures for converting files and document these procedures in writing. It may be helpful to enlist a reputable commercial organization to assist in this process.

 

If a registrant wishes to destroy the original paper copies, they should first ensure the digital copies have been duplicated accurately and allow the registrant to meet all record-keeping obligations.

 

Old paper records should not be destroyed unless the required retention period has expired or the entire paper-based record has been duplicated accurately in electronic format. (See Items 34 to 39 in CPSO’s “Medical Records Management”, linked below for related guidance.)

 

Question: 

How do I determine who is the “health information custodian”?

 

Answer: 

CRPO often receives questions about who is responsible for health information recorded by a registrant. The answer to this question depends on identifying the “health information custodian.” The term “health information custodian” is defined in the Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004 (PHIPA). In short, a custodian is an individual or organization that has custody or control of personal health information.

 

If practising alone, a registrant is the health information custodian of their clients’ information. If employed by another health information custodian such as a hospital, the employer is the health information custodian and the registrant is expected to follow the record management practices of their employer.

 

Where a registrant is employed by a non-health organization such a school, university, college or municipality, the registrant is considered to be the custodian. In these situations, the registrant cannot disclose personal health information to their employer without the client’s consent or another legal exception.

 

In other situations, the answer may not be clear, and registrants will need to speak with their employer/organization. The Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (IPC) also has resources on this topic. (See the IPC’s PHIPA Frequently Asked Questions in Related Resources linked below.)

 

Question:

How do I properly destroy my client files?

 

Answer: 

Records, including clinical records, appointment records, and financial records, need to be kept for 10 years from the last interaction with the client or from the client’s 18th birthday, whichever is later. (See Standard 5.1: Clinical Records, linked in Related Resources below.)

 

When the time period for keeping the record has expired, the records should be destroyed. If the therapist destroys any records, they should record the names of the destroyed files and the date they were destroyed. For paper records, destruction means cross-cut shredding, not simply continuous (single strip) shredding, which can be reconstructed. You should consider pulverization or incineration of records that are highly sensitive. You might also hire a licensed service provider to destroy your files. In doing so, look for a provider accredited by an industrial trade association, such as the National Association for Information Destruction (NAID).

 

The Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (IPC) has a Technology Fact Sheet on the topic of disposing of electronic media, as well as a Fact Sheet on Secure Destruction of Personal Information, linked in Related Resources below.

 

 

For questions about confidentiality and health records, contact the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario.

Toronto Area: 416-326-3333
Toll Free: 1-800-387-0073
[email protected]

Related Resources

For additional information, see the resources below.

  • Standard 5.6

    Record Storage, Security, & Retrieval

    The Professional Practice Standards regarding record storage, security, and retrieval.

    Read more
  • College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario

    Medical Records Management

    Whether in paper or electronic format, physicians must comply with all relevant legislation and regulatory requirements related to medical record-keeping.

    Read more
  • Information & Privacy Commissioner of Ontario

    PHIPA Frequently Asked Questions

    This FAQ provides a general overview of the Personal Health Information Protection Act and Regulation 329/04.

    Read more
  • Ontario Government

    Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004

    PHIPA allows health information custodians to engage the services of agents. For example, administrative staff or technical support providers could be considered an agent of the health information custodian.

    Read more
  • Professional Practice Standards

    Standards & Regulations for Registered Psychotherapists

    The practice standards deal with issues of general professionalism and conduct, such as conflict-of-interest, confidentiality of client information, consent and record-keeping.

    Read more
  • Information & Privacy Commissioner of Ontario

    Disposing of Your Electronic Media

    This fact sheet provides guidance on how Ontario public institutions and health information custodians can securely destroy personal information when disposing of electronic media.

    Read more
  • Standard 5.1

    Standard 5.1: Clinical Records

    The Professional Practice Standards regarding clinical records. This includes the two standards, examples in demonstrating the standard, and related resources.

    Read more
  • Information Privacy Commissioner of Ontario

    Fact Sheet: Secure Destruction of Personal Information

    This fact sheet includes suggested best practices for the destruction of personal information.

    Read more
  • Information Privacy Commissioner of Ontario

    A Privacy Management Handbook for Small Health Care Organizations, May 2025

    This handbook offers practical guidance to help smaller organizations meet their privacy obligations under Ontario’s health privacy law.

     

    It includes foundational components of a privacy management program such as governance and accountability, privacy policies, privacy procedures and controls, and ongoing monitoring and review.

    Read more

Join our mailing list and stay up to date with the latest news

Sign up to receive news and information from us.

Sign Up Today